Dr Who

[Guest]

[Roz]

Wow Leah, I thought you were in America... perhaps you are doing what a lot of Brits do to see American TV - good luck to you

What did you guys think of both eps together? I was cooking and so didn't really get to truly appreciate the episode (and I missed Dr Who Confidential - Leah, make sure you get that, it rather enhances the occasion ). I didn't read the radio times as my brother stole it and took it to his room... ahh I'll be out of family life again as of this afternoon and boy, I'll miss it - off into the big wide world again.

Dawn you finally got the Blue suit in these 2 eps

[Angels]

I loved the double episode and my favourite part was when the 2 Daleks were talking about trusting the leader and looked round to make sure no one was listening. Such a human trait, it really made me smile. 

The confidential is a must see as it shows just how much work goes into creating each episode, right down to the smallest detail.

[Sharon]

Well from a few episodes where I raved about how brilliant they were, to a two part-er with the ultimate villains that was blah  .  The script was lacking, the story had more holes than our road and the continuity with what we already know about this Doctor was very poor.  I think Angles picked up on the best bit of the whole episode - the Daleks checking for evesdroppers 

Was it just me or was the willingness of Doctor Who to help the Daleks totally unbelievable.  I can't accept he would have helped Zec(?) with the first DNA experiment and when he offered to save the last Dalek in existence all credibility went out of the window.  We know this Doctor can be quite ruthless and that he hates the Daleks with a vengeance - if it wasn't for them his people would be alive and he would still be with his beloved Rose.  I just don't buy for one second that he would miss the chance of wiping them from history, even if it did mean another genocide.  All in all I was very disappointed, as you may have guessed 

[gimli]

I loved the first two series but i have to say that I think they have just lost their way this series It just isn't so good I hope things get better It would be a shame if it keeps going the way it is

I have to say I think the worst episodes are the ones by Russell T Davies but i have always thought that throughout all the series

[Sharon]

I have to say I think the worst episodes are the ones by Russell T Davies but i have always thought that throughout all the series

That's so strange, Boggy and my other brother say the same thing.  They thought the last two episodes were written by him they were so bad but he wasn't to blame this time.

[Morningangel-Iola]

Well from a few episodes where I raved about how brilliant they were, to a two part-er with the ultimate villains that was blah  .  The script was lacking, the story had more holes than our road and the continuity with what we already know about this Doctor was very poor.  I think Angles picked up on the best bit of the whole episode - the Daleks checking for evesdroppers 

Was it just me or was the willingness of Doctor Who to help the Daleks totally unbelievable.  I can't accept he would have helped Zec(?) with the first DNA experiment and when he offered to save the last Dalek in existence all credibility went out of the window.  We know this Doctor can be quite ruthless and that he hates the Daleks with a vengeance - if it wasn't for them his people would be alive and he would still be with his beloved Rose.  I just don't buy for one second that he would miss the chance of wiping them from history, even if it did mean another genocide.  All in all I was very disappointed, as you may have guessed 

I loved the evesdropping check too lol.

I think he went along with Sec was he saw how good the human eliment was for the Daleks, more thought less fighting.

I think its the fact that they are now both the last two that he was handing out an olive branch.

But thats just my angle on it all.

[De Orc]

Part 2 was to say the least very weak. I loved the bit with the 2 Daleks that was classic humour, yes I agree that this DR can be ruthless but He had thought that he had commited double genocide once previously & I dont think that rested to well with him, so offering the Daleks a chance was understandable

De Orc 

[Morningangel-Iola]

Bad news, the week of Euro Vision,  there will be NO DR WHO!  :'(

[LMangue]

Wow Leah, I thought you were in America... perhaps you are doing what a lot of Brits do to see American TV - good luck to you

What did you guys think of both eps together? I was cooking and so didn't really get to truly appreciate the episode (and I missed Dr Who Confidential - Leah, make sure you get that, it rather enhances the occasion ). I didn't read the radio times as my brother stole it and took it to his room... ahh I'll be out of family life again as of this afternoon and boy, I'll miss it - off into the big wide world again.

Dawn you finally got the Blue suit in these 2 eps

hehe, I am in America!   Yep, I'm getting them the only way I can, ahem.  A girl does what she must to get her WHO fix.  I eagerly await Sat afternoons as that's when "it/they" is/are posted.  By dinner I'm able to watch the latest episodes.

I'm getting on top of the Dr. Who Confidential situation as well.  Darn it...so far behind!

I have to say that I liked the two-parter, a little less than the others but I figure not every ep's going to be perfect.  I'm sure they've got more solid stuff to be had in the eps to come.  Nothing can pry me away at this point.  I'm hooked.

[Morningangel-Iola]

Oh right I see, I think. Anna is dieing to see the new series, I do keep teasing her

[LMangue]

hehe, teasing.  Poor dear.
bit torrents are my friend, another Who fan told me I could at least catch up with those.

[Morningangel-Iola]

And she never used to know about Dr Who and then I got her started, I am naughty. It was my fan fiction what dun it.

[LMangue]

And she never used to know about Dr Who and then I got her started, I am naughty. It was my fan fiction what dun it.

Hm, curiosity peaked.  I'm interested to know what spark of writing prompted a full-fledged fan happening.
  Nothing naughty about spreading the love!

[Morningangel-Iola]

There's a link to my stories in this thread http://www.theyakshack.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,5076.0.html

Dr who world domination

[LMangue]

Thank you!  I can see why she was drawn in!  Very nice!
Good luck on the competition.

[Morningangel-Iola]

Thanks

Thanks, hopefully we'll hear this month

[LMangue]

...Leah, make sure you get that, it rather enhances the occasion...

All caught up.  Those are great!

[Morningangel-Iola]

Good episode, but why did they make so much fuss about 'Mavis' being in it, she was dead with a couple of minutes

And what did that man tell Martha's mum? Is he really the Master or similar, so just some nosey so and so.

[Sharon]

The Doctor is back in the house .  That was just so much better than the last two it is hard to believe they are all in the same series.  I totally agree Dawn about Mavis - right up to the last two minutes I was expecting her to resurrect and attack someone.

When I asked Boggy who that man was he straight away said the Master.  I think he may have been someone from Torchwood though as the very long preview for the next episode has everyones favourite, Captain Jack 

Oh and in the paper today one columnist makes the comment that Daniel (007) Craig could learn a thing or two from David about how to wear a tux 

[Morningangel-Iola]

Sorry Captian Jack isn't in the nest episode to my knowledge.

David was on Parky last night and he said there wasn't a time lord hanging about, that its a lot more complicated than that.

I know which I would rather