Time to rate Trilogy!!

[Guest]

[Goofyjas]

Ok time to rate them as you would want to pull them, best to worst, AND as you would rate the price of them ( though I am sure the Faramir is going to be the top of the price list)

AUTOGRAPHS OVERALL - 1:18
LEVEL A - 1:19
1) NOEL APPLEBY
2) SALA BAKER
3) BILLY BOYD
4) BERNARD HILL
5) IAN HOLM
6) BRUCE HOPKINS
7) BRET MCKENZIE
8 ) VIGGO MORTENSEN (ARAGORN)
9) VIGGO MORTENSEN (KING ELESSAR)
10) JOHN NOBLE
11) LIV TYLER
12) KARL URBAN
13) STEPHEN URE

LEVEL B - 1:320
14) DAVID WENHAM  

MEMORABILIA CARDS OVERALL - 1:36
1) ELROND'S RIVENDELL ROBE - 1:200
2) THE WITCH-KING'S ROBE - 1:232
3) ARAGORN'S HOUSE OF HEALING SHIRT - 1:250  
4) FRODO'S ELVEN TUNIC - 1:262
5) EOWYN'S EDORAS STABLES DRESS - 1:300
6) BILBO'S GREY HAVENS WAISTCOAT - 1:385  
7) EOWYN'S GOLDEN HALL DRESS  1:550
8 ) SAM'S ELVEN TUNIC - 1:652
9) PIPPIN'S GONDORIAN TUNIC - 1:691

[Roz]

Well, in the Roz line up the top 4 have to be

1) Elessar auto
2) Aragorn auto (hmm the order of those two might change when I see them )
3) Sauron auto
4) Aragorn Clothing card

And bottom of my list?

Proudfoot

very bottom of my list... FIGWIT -

sorry I just don't see the appeal  

[gimli]

well this is what i would like to pull most and i have to say i prefer some of the easier costumes as i think they will be more interesting

1) VIGGO MORTENSEN (KING ELESSAR)
2) SALA BAKER
3) JOHN NOBLE
4) IAN HOLM
5) LIV TYLER
6) DAVID WENHAM
7) KARL URBAN
BERNARD HILL
9) BILLY BOYD
10) VIGGO MORTENSEN (ARAGORN)
11) BRUCE HOPKINS
12) STEPHEN URE
13) NOEL APPLEBY
14) BRET MCKENZIE

1) PIPPIN'S GONDORIAN TUNIC - 1:691
2) BILBO'S GREY HAVENS WAISTCOAT - 1:385
3) ARAGORN'S HOUSE OF HEALING SHIRT - 1:250
4) ELROND'S RIVENDELL ROBE - 1:200
5) FRODO'S ELVEN TUNIC - 1:262
6) EOWYN'S EDORAS STABLES DRESS - 1:300
7) EOWYN'S GOLDEN HALL DRESS  1:550
THE WITCH-KING'S ROBE - 1:232
9) SAM'S ELVEN TUNIC - 1:652

[Goofyjas]

I think I would have to say.. the following

Though I only got 1 case and hope to finish a set with extras

VIGGO MORTENSEN (KING ELESSAR) 1
SALA BAKER 2
LIV TYLER 3
VIGGO MORTENSEN (ARAGORN) 4
DAVID WENHAM  5
NOEL APPLEBY 6
BILLY BOYD 7
BERNARD HILL 8
KARL URBAN 9
STEPHEN URE 10
IAN HOLM 11
BRUCE HOPKINS 12
JOHN NOBLE 13
BRET MCKENZIE 14


ARAGORN'S HOUSE OF HEALING SHIRT 1
BILBO'S GREY HAVENS WAISTCOAT 2
FRODO'S ELVEN TUNIC 3
SAM'S ELVEN TUNIC 4
PIPPIN'S GONDORIAN TUNIC 5
ELROND'S RIVENDELL ROBE 6
EOWYN'S EDORAS STABLES DRESS 7
EOWYN'S GOLDEN HALL DRESS 8
THE WITCH-KING'S ROBE 9

[Roz]

It's actually quite a clever twist making the Viggo auto into an Elessar one - look at us all putting it at the top there with Sala. Those 2 are going to be pricey if this lot of demand is anything to go by!

[beckham1]

I don't know what everyone thinks, but I wonder if these cards are going to be in rather short supply and therefore in high $$$ demand.

I just can't imagine by three inserts per box, that the production run was very high.  I am sure preorders were low.

What does anyone else think or does anyone know the cases or boxes produced?

[samwise16]

I reckon it will be as good as HP, maybe not £100 a box within 3 weeks but it will be close  

[savage727]

My only interest at this point is the 2 Aragorn Auto Cards, the Aragorn Clothing Card, and the Sala Baker Auto Card.  

There is no interest by any of the Card Shops in my area to carry this product as they did very poorly with the last several releases.  

I think we may be seeing the LOTR's running its course and losing interest with many as evidenced by the total lack of orders for this product.  Roz sent me an article telling how Topps has plans for other LOTR's card sets.  I wonder if that will hold true now based on what went on with Trilogy?

[robwaddle]

Ratings:

1. Figgy

2. Figgy

3. Figgy

4. Figgy

5. Proudfeet

6. Proudfeet

etc etc.........

 

Sorry, couldn't resist  

Rob