I think an inch is the norm. 2 just seemed like an awful lot. An inch will definitely make the shirt more fitted on me, but not too bad (probably still loser than a lot of younger girls wear

) I just don't want the length to go.
Do not wash, Do not wash.....If it was only an inch, then the larger one would definitely still have been baggy looking. And with that shirt, I would have wanted the sleeves to shrink quite a bit. Sounds like that might not of happened. Can you notice if the sleeve holes got any smaller? Probably not, that is asking a lot

Oh, and were they youth size shirts you got? The thicker or light weight material?