HBP Blooper ?????

[Guest]

[Sharon]

I was unsure which topic to put this in so I thought I would start a new one    If you are reading this post I am assuming you have read GOF and seen the film.
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
I have just seen the GOF film and was a bit put out by the graveyard scene where Harry fights Voldemort.  Harry is tied to the gravestone and Voldemort is doing the usual baddie speech.  He tells Harry he knows why he lost his powers when Harry was a baby.  He says it was because Lily loved Harry so much and that he (Voldemort) hadn't taken the ancient magic into account.

Now all of this is true but didn't Dumbledore have the same talk with Harry in the HBP?  Except in that book DD said that Voldemort didn't know why he lost his powers, that he never acknowledged the power of love and that was how Voldemort could be defeated.  Any thoughts would be appreciated, even if it is to say I am being too picky.

[EmmasOneandOnly]

I dont think this is a blooper...they film a movie backwards so HBP wasnt even out

[kbmum]

I just checked my GOF book.  Voldemort does mention that Lily saved Harry with an old magic that he was foolish to overlook.

[Sharon]

Thank you, I thought you would know 

Mike I thought what you did at first but then remembered that JKR approves all the scripts, so she would have known what was in the HBP.

Of course all of this does rather blow DD's game plan in HBP 

[Sharon]

I have amended the title of this topic cos I didn't want to start a new one and this one is really small 

Anyway did anyone else hear on the news today that there was an error in HBP about Hermiones exam results.  Apparently in Order of the Phoenix she was sitting 10 exams but in HBP she states she passed 11 exams.  I didn't hear it myself but my other brother (not Boggy) rang to say they were going to be changing it in the next print run.

I was going to check it out but I want to resist - I have decided to re-read all the books in order (without jumping to my favourite bits  ) before book 7.  I just know if I go to look this up I will start reading HBP again and it will blow my whole plan.  Can anyone remember if the 10/11 exams thing is correct?

[Morningangel-Iola]

I can't say I noticed, some people ate just eagle eyed.

[Bogleg]

I didn't hear it myself but my other brother (not Boggy) rang to say they were going to be changing it in the next print run.

Sharon has another brother    Next thing you know, she'll start saying he's a spiky haired, tattooed, leather clad, boot-wearing lad with lots of piercings 

[Roz]

I've seen a piccy of all three of you Boggy... although admittedly there were no piercings at the time