The Yak Shack Forum

Here is my first choice.  I don't think I can keep both and have narrowed it down to these two Arwen sketches.  They are both lovely so I would appreciate it if you all would give me your thoughts:
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v472/dlecours1313/ArwensWalksGH.jpg)

Wow, that's so tough.  :-\  I think the one on the right has more emotion in it, but the one on the left shows the cool headdress (is that what you call it?).  I guess I would keep the one on the right.

If I had to make the choice, I would go for the one on the right as well!

I can take Russel's  for you .. then you won't have to worry about it anymore. :o=

Sure Cat just send that Saruman sketch over! 

I would take Walks....but that is just me.

I like the one on the left better, so if you do decide to part with it be sure to let me know ;)

Um... you have to talk to the woman in Canada for that.. she owns it now ;)

I would keep the Walks sketch Dave  ;)

I'd keep the Walks.  It looks more like Liv Tyler.

So sorry, which one is Walk's?  I think the one on the left looks more like Liv, so I would keep that one ;)

*psst* Sara ... Russ Walks sketch is the one on the left  ;)
.... the one on the right is by Gabriel Hernandez I believe?

Thanks Jules ;D  Yup, I like the one on the left :)

I'll put my vote in for the Walks too! The Hernandez one is lovely as well though yucky. Send it to me and I will take it off your hands. I will even pay postage (:D# :rofl:

According to the sketch card site, Gabriel Hernandez only did 80 sketches (opposed to Walks' 200), so I would keep the Hernandez since I like both cards the same. ;)

http://www.lotrsketchcards.com/

Are you crazy?  There's only one choice to make...KEEP THEM BOTH!!! >:()

He has a point. ;)

I'd keep them both - they're by two different artists.

Now if you already HAVE one by each artist, then I'd keep the Walks because the headdress/crown/whatever is cool.

I still have 15 artists to go I think...

I would pick the one on the right - It just speaks to me ... not sure what she's saying, but she's definately saying "Keep me ..."

Dave:

I would keep them both as well because it shows Arwen in two completely different stages of the movies.   :)

If you don't need to sell them, keep them both! Why sell one anyway?

I like the Walks better but Hernandez is much rarer and it is still a very nice card, one of his best I have seen. I'd keep them both for sure.

I have to sell one because my credit card company apparantly has this thing where they want the virtual money I spend paid back |:#.  I want to keep at least one Kayanan and can only keep so many other cards.  Also with HP and WOZ coming out I can't keep 'em all.

I'd sell something else... they're both fantastic!

Sell your Kayanan elf warrior instead. The Arwens are much nicer to keep.

Oh I have plenty of others to list, but I will never get the $'s I need to pay the bill selling Hogkins, Martinez, and Shums

Dave, I also like the Walks better!!  8)

*tsk tsk* these credit card companies are just so unreasonable ... forcing you to sell your cards ... heartless people!! ::)  :'( :(

Well, the Walks sketch seems to be the hot favourite so far Dave - will you keep it or are you going to be ruthless and let her go? :-\

The one thing that tips the scale for me is that the Hernandez Arwen (though an absolute masterpiece) has that LOTR logo squarely in the middle of her head. No fault of the artist,  but it does make the Walks more appealing :)